ANNI MIRABILES: 5BC
What was the most important year ever? Andrew Marr suggests it was probably 1776, but Adrian Wooldridge, The Economist's Washington bureau chief, has another idea ...
From INTELLIGENT LIFE Magazine, Summer 2009
The most important year in history is both easy to identify and hard to pinpoint. Easy to identify because we use it to divide our calendar into “before” and “after”. Hard to pinpoint because there is some confusion about whether we got the calendar right.
You do not have to be a believer (and the author of this article is not) to recognise that Jesus’s birth was the most important event in human history. Jesus inspired the world’s most popular religion and plays an important role in both Judaism and Islam. But he also shaped all subsequent secular history. The Roman Catholic church is the world’s oldest global institution. The Reformation, which helped to inspire individualism and capitalism, was an attempt to return the church to its original purity. The French and Russian revolutions were inspired, in large part, by hatred of the religious establishment. Two thousand years after Jesus’s birth, about 2 billion people, or a third of the world’s population, call themselves Christians.
The frustrating thing is that we cannot pinpoint Jesus’s birth-year exactly. The Christian calendar presumes that it took place in year 1—everything before that is BC. But modern scholars have complicated the picture. The Gospel of Matthew places Jesus’s birth under the reign of Herod the Great, who died in 4BC. The Gospel of Luke says that he was born during the first census of Judea in 6AD. The consensus is that he was born between 6 and 4BC. Let’s call it 5BC for the sake of simplicity—not as clear-cut as some of the other dates suggested, but then the year of Jesus’s birth is such a momentous event that it makes other contenders for the most important year look feeble by comparison.
In the coming days, other Economist writers will cast their votes for the most important year ever, and then you can cast yours (see poll at right).
Picture credit: Alan Kitching
(Adrian Wooldridge is The Economist's bureau chief in Washington and co-author most recently of the book "God is Back: How the Global Revival of Faith Is Changing the World". His last article for Intelligent Life was about the rise of the journo-gurus.)
Email this page
Delicious
StumbleUpon
Facebook
Comments
The most important date in history
August 7, 2009 - 06:14 — Brian E (not verified)Of those listed the birth of Jesus was clearly the most important, although I could argue that his death was even more important
"The Gospel of Luke says
August 7, 2009 - 13:26 — Visitor (not verified)"The Gospel of Luke says that he was born during the first census of Judea in 6AD."
Should that have read 6BC? Otherwise the decision to pick 5BC as the average seems odd.
Jesus Christ
August 7, 2009 - 14:09 — len (not verified)The birth , life, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ are without doubt the most important dates in the History of the Universe.
I thoroughly agree with the
August 7, 2009 - 16:32 — John Wallace (not verified)I thoroughly agree with the statement that the birth, life, death and resurrection of our Lord Jesus Christ are the most important dates in our history.
Amen.
August 10, 2009 - 11:00 — Visitor (not verified)Anyone who says otherwise is living in a fantasy.
Everything changed after Christ's birth and the drive towards modernity began because, despite what modern scholars will have us believe, this was the first time that large swaths of men and women started treating poor people with kindness for no reason at all.
Charity gave birth to science.
In an English class I once had a girl suggest that the writings of Shakespeare might outdo the bible as the most important collection of writings in human history.
I raised my hand and asked how many times the bible quotes Shakespeare.
I am sure 6 BC is the
August 11, 2009 - 12:09 — Sharpe Books (not verified)I am sure 6 BC is the genrally agreed histocial date of the birth of Jesus Christ.
I also pretty sure no established church really claims 1 AD, we all know the monk made a mistake.
Date of Jesus' birth.
August 13, 2009 - 19:09 — Phil W (not verified)Jesus would almost certainly have been born before 4 BC. Herod died some time between March 12 (eclipse) and April 11 (Passover) in 4 BC (Josephus, Ant. 17.191; 17.197; 17.213), and Matthew's reference to Herod slaughtering infants under the age of 2 after questioning the Magi (Mt. 2:16, 19-20) suggests a date 2 or more years before Herod's death.
Luke puts it in the reign of Caesar Augustus (44 BC - AD 14), although the mention of the census while Quirinius was governor of Syria throws a spanner in the works because Quirinius was governor in 6/7 AD. It is possible that Quirinius was also a legate to Syria in 7/6 BC, if the Roman citizen mentioned in the "Tiburtine Inscription" (CIL XIV, 3613) is also him, which would make the most likely date 6 BC. This would accord well with Luke's description of Jesus as a man in his thirties when he began his ministry in the late 20's AD (Luke 3:23) - if Luke had meant to imply Jesus was born in 6 AD then he would be too young for the description given.
Jesus Christ and the Bible
August 17, 2009 - 03:32 — Christmas Gifts (not verified)It is difficult to use the Bible as a factual reference point. Scholars believe that it was written anything between 300-800 years after the birth of Jesus. Like so many stories of this time, the facts were passed from family to family over the years.
Whilst I am of the belief, that the actual birth of Christ was within 5 years of 0AD, it is difficult to use the Bible as a factual reference point to prove this.
Factual?
October 16, 2009 - 07:46 — Emma Bridgewater (not verified)I was always told it was 4BC as if it was a fact... I can understand how there can't be a specific date but I'm actually quite suprised to see so many dates being flown around.
dates
November 6, 2009 - 07:15 — Game of Thrones (not verified)Many dates have been suggested emma, though the most significantly 5 BC abd 6BC.
If soemone was teaching 4 BC as absoulte fact they were being a little over zealous.
The best thign we have to date the Birth is the Census.
If his birth year is really
December 10, 2009 - 15:04 — Jesus birth (not verified)If his birth year is really 1 AD or not should matter less, what is really important is what he did with his life. He sacrificed himself for us, for our sins and this is what makes him so important.
The most important date in history...
February 24, 2010 - 12:27 — Dolly (not verified)GOD says know one knows the day when JESUS CHRIST our LORD will come again. This will be the most important date. Keep your eye on the sparrow. It is absolutely wonderful to see so many people in agreement that JESUS's birthday was the most important day in history...I do not think it is coincidence that know one seems to know the date from when HE first came to us, and know one know's the date when He will come again.
Blessings to all brothers and sisters in CHrist for doing His will and work.
Post new comment